The hidden cost of recognition absence on employee wellbeing

All Sectors

By Tracey Paxton, Clinical Director at Perkbox

There is something deeply discouraging about putting considerable effort into work and feeling that nobody notices. An employee might spend weeks helping a colleague through a difficult project or become the person everyone relies on when something needs doing. But when someone else receives public praise for a contribution that seems no greater than their own, they begin wondering why their own efforts weren’t recognised.

As human beings, people want to feel that what they do matters, that their contribution is noticed and that they’re treated fairly. There is also a fundamental need to belong, and feeling appreciated helps reinforce that sense of connection. According to research of 4,000 UK employees, 57% say reward and recognition improve their wellbeing, yet only 29% report that their manager recognises good work on an ongoing basis.

No one can possibly expect to be praised every time they do something well. But when employees find themselves regularly overlooked, especially when others get the accolades, it can start to affect their confidence and overall wellbeing.

How feeling overlooked affects wellbeing

Recognition gives the feeling that people’s efforts have been seen and valued. If a manager takes the time to acknowledge a contribution, it can go a long way toward reinforcing an employee’s confidence in their abilities and the value they bring to the team. In the absence of that recognition, the employee can start to question themselves. Are they doing enough? Does their manager actually value what they do? Why on earth are they working so hard?

What starts off as just disappointment at a missed acknowledgement can quite easily escalate into frustration and a sense of being taken for granted. There’s also the well-documented phenomenon of negativity bias, where the brain is wired to pay more attention to the negative. Once started down the path of feeling unappreciated, an employee can become very sensitive to anything that confirms that.

This doesn’t mean their concerns are unfounded. Sometimes recognition genuinely is distributed unfairly. Almost one in four employees (23%) believe workplace rewards are influenced by personal relationships rather than contribution. Meanwhile, only 39% understand how reward decisions are made. When people cannot understand why some contributions are recognised, and others aren’t, they may start filling in the gaps themselves, often assuming they’re simply less valued.

That uncertainty can have an impact on the level of comfort people feel in their teams. People can become quite preoccupied with the question of whether they’re being treated fairly or how their manager sees them. Over time, that can lead to resentment and more difficult working relationships, with people feeling less connected to their colleagues.

Why a thank-you can feel hollow

The answer isn’t simply to praise people more often. Recognition that feels automatic or insincere can be equally disappointing.

Consider a manager who thanks everyone at the end of a meeting for their hard work. It’s a pleasant gesture, but an employee who has spent days resolving a difficult problem may leave wondering whether their manager understands what they’ve actually contributed. Compare that with a manager who acknowledges the effort involved in resolving that problem and explains how it helped the team. The employee understands why their work was appreciated.

A routine thank-you can feel hollow when it could have been directed at anyone. Employees want to feel recognised as individuals, particularly when they have invested considerable effort in their work.

Fairness also has an impact on how recognition is received. If the same people are constantly being recognised without any justification, people may start to wonder whether it’s down to personal relationships. The manager may not have intended to create that impression at all. Some managers are more comfortable giving praise, while others assume their team knows they’re doing a good job.

That inconsistency can leave employees with very different experiences of the same workplace.

Why feeling valued looks different for everyone

Employees don’t necessarily want the same things from work, and recognition can contribute to wellbeing in different ways. For some, a financial reward provides meaningful acknowledgement. Others may appreciate being trusted with greater responsibility or having their judgement respected.

These preferences can change throughout someone’s career. Among employees aged 55–64, 43% identify being trusted as one of their biggest workplace motivators, compared with 26% of those aged 18–24. There are also people whose reliability makes them effectively invisible. They’re the ones who will always be there to support a colleague, who will always be there to sort things out. Over time, their contribution becomes something that is just expected of them.

Managers can quite easily miss these people as they know the work will get done. Over time, that can lead to people feeling undervalued and consequently lose their motivation to go the extra mile.

To understand what employees value, managers need to have regular conversations. They need to know what makes someone feel valued rather than just assume that the same thing will have the same effect on all. Wellbeing at work is in part a function of the day-to-day working relationships. Feeling heard, having contributions recognised, and knowing recognition will be fairly distributed can all affect whether employees feel supported at work.

Employees don’t need constant praise, but they do need to believe their work matters, that they’re treated fairly, and that they belong. When those feelings disappear, employees may continue doing their jobs well, but gradually withdraw emotionally.

The psychological cost can be difficult to see. Someone may still meet deadlines and support colleagues while privately feeling less confident and increasingly disconnected. By the time that surfaces, the damage to their wellbeing and trust is already irreparable.

Disclaimer: The views expressed in this opinion piece are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Well Crowd. This content is for information and discussion purposes only and should not be taken as medical, health, or professional advice.

The List. Trusted Expertise. Easier to Find

The List connects organisations with credible UK providers across workplace wellbeing and workforce health. Part of The Well Crowd’s intelligence platform, it helps decision-makers explore support, and providers showcase their expertise.

Better intelligence. Better workforce decisions.

Stay ahead of the latest research, emerging trends and industry developments shaping workforce health and wellbeing. Explore expert insights, fresh perspectives and practical resources through The Well Crowd's Intelligence Hub.